Cathy startles him when she whips open the dressing room curtain and stands there with only a tiny red bikini bra and translucent lace panties that exposes every naked feature of her private body parts.
“Damn it Cathy! Cover yourself up,” he says as he steps forward and pushes her back into the dressing room. He looks around to make sure no one sees her dressed like that.
“Are you ashamed of me, Daddy?”
“No! I just don’t want you exposed like that for everyone to see.”
“Do you think I’m ugly?”
“No! I think you are beautiful, but damn it, I don’t want you on display for the whole world to see.”
The bra and panty exposes everything to anyone who may pass near the dressing room. Jim can see her thin black patch covering her pubic mound and her hard nipples that are trying to burst through the tiny lace bra. Cathy takes his right hand and places it on her left breast. He reflexively cradles it and rolls the nipple between his thumb and index finger. Her low moan shakes him back to his senses and he jerks his hand away like it is on fire.
“Get dressed!” he says backing out of the dressing room. “We are going to get lunch and talk.”
They settle into a corner booth at the rear of TGI Friday. The lighting is low and not really suitable for his intended Father/Daughter talk. After lunch while drinking a cup of coffee, Jim launches into the lecture he had quietly rehearsed to himself while eating lunch.
“Cathy you have to stop trying to get me back in your bed. I am your Father and it is called incest if we have sex together.”
“Frankly Dad, I don’t see anything wrong with incest at our age. Sure, I understand the emotional problems it can cause a young girl having her first sexual experience. I read all the papers in Uni. when I took psychology. I am talking about right now; you and I are both mature adults. I had a healthy first sexual experience with someone my own age when I was a teenager. I am emotional stable when it comes to sex. I think you and I can have sex together as two consenting adults without it emotionally destabilizing either of us.”
Jim is conflicted. She is starting to make sense. He is attracted to her sexually and he did enjoy their first impromptu sexual coupling the other night. He still thinks it will cause guilt because it will be cheating on Lucy. He wants Cathy really bad, but he doesn’t want to hurt Lucy or destroy his marriage.
“I understand your thinking, Baby and I agree it wouldn’t hurt you emotionally like it would have as a teenager, but it would hurt your Mother if she ever found out.”
Cathy reaches across the table, taking his hands in hers and says, “We don’t have to let her know about it. We can be very discreet about it.”